Alternative Law Journal

Abstracts, December 2002

Line Image

Volume 27, No 6, December 2002

 

Articles

Briefs

 

Articles

Righting the wrong: Achieving reparations for the Stolen Generations
by John T Rush QC

The life stories of Lorna Cubillo and Peter Gunner - the two representatives of the stolen generations at the centre of Cubillo and Gunner v Commonwealth of Australia [2000] FCA 1084 - are detailed, stories that the trial judge, O'Loughlin J, accepted as the circumstances of their removal and detention. The defeat of their claims is briefly discussed and a call is made to right the wrong done to them and the many other members of the stolen generations.

Repairing the damage: Achieving reparations for the Stolen Generations
by Andrea Durbach

The difficulties posed by litigation for the stolen generations and the need for redress for victims of forcible removal policies, formed the basis of a Public Interest Advocacy Centre proposal for the establishment of a Stolen Generations Reparations Tribunal. 'Repairing the damage - achieving reparations for the stolen generations' explores the development of a mechanism which offers a culturally appropriate and compassionate response to the injustices endured by members of the stolen generations.

Who's the addict? The need for pokie reform in Victoria
by Paul Ronalds

This article discusses the regulation of gambling in Victoria and examines recent reforms introduced by the Bracks Government. It also looks at recommendations of the Inter-Church Gambling Taskforce to the way gambling is conducted in Victoria.

Homelessness and human rights: Engaging human rights discourse in the Australian context
by Dianne Otto

This article examines the effectiveness of the 'indirect' (political rather than judicial) methods of implementation employed by Australian governments to fulfil their international human rights obligations by using the national Supported Accommodation Assistance Program (SAAP) as a case study. The case study reveals that the main problems with indirect approaches to human rights implementation are the lack of independent accountability mechanisms and the related absence of effective remedies in the event of a violation. Despite these shortcomings, the author suggests that there are many ways in which indirect implementation can be strengthened and urges critical engagement with Australian governments towards this end.

Living in public space: a human rights wasteland?
by Cassandra Goldie

This article tells the story of Sam and John, two homeless men living in public space around Darwin in the Northern Territory. In August 1996, there were over 105,000 homeless people across Australia. The author examines the human rights of people living in public space.

Drug courts: Sentencing responses to drug use and drug-related crime
by Arie Freiberg

This article discusses Victoria's new drug court, which focuses on identifying and addressing the underlying causes of drug use and drug-related crime. It is the fifth such court in Australia. They are part of an emerging trend in judicial administration that has seen the development of what have been termed 'problem-oriented courts'. They represent a move away from a focus on individuals and their criminal conduct to offenders' problems and their solutions.

Detention of asylum seekers: Interpreting the Migration Act
by Anoushka Bondar

In four cases currently before the Federal Court of Australia in which the legality of the detention of individual asylum seekers is contested, interlocutory orders have been made by the Court for the release of the asylum seekers, pending the hearing and determination of each substantive proceeding. In the hearing of each interlocutory application, several issues arose for consideration which required an interpretation of provisions of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), including whether the Court's power to make the orders sought pursuant to s.23 of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth), was removed or limited by provisions of that Act. Ultimately, the question of the grant of relief turned on whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of the relief sought, and in each case, significant weight was given to the continued deprivation of the liberty of the applicant and the harm which had ensued from that detention.

Briefs

Capital Punishment: Death for the most deserving
by Greg Heaton

This brief discusses two recent US cases that have narrowed the categories of people who can be given the death penalty in the United States. One case, Atkins v Virginia, decided that mentally retarded people cannot be executed and a second, Ring v Arizona decided that judges alone cannot impose the death sentence as this violates the constitutional right to trial by jury.

Human Rights: After Johannesburg; can human rights be privatised too?
by Adam McBeth and David Kinley

This brief examines the implications under international human rights law for the 'partnerships for sustainable development' emerging from the recent World Summit for Sustainable Development in Johannesburg, and for the general trend towards private provision of social services.

Humanitarian Law: Teaching international humanitarian law and values to secondary school students
by Kobi-Renée Leins

A report on a 'refugee game' used by the International Red Cross to educate secondary school students about what it means to be a displaced person, asylum seeker or refugee.

| Back to Past Editions | Back to Alt LJ Home Page |

Line Image

Comments or suggestions on the pages to Liz.Boulton@law.monash.edu.au Blue Ribbon Campaign Image